How much of your company's training is a waste of time and money?
Clients often ask, “What’s the best metric for measuring training effectiveness?”
It’s an important question, because it can be difficult to correlate communication skills training directly to cost savings or revenue increases — the kind of “hard” return on investment numbers that executives like to see.
But, there is one metric that does resonate with most executives.
Executives get the idea of waste.
Most executives understand the idea of waste — money and time invested that provides no business benefit. That’s why the idea of “scrap learning” is so important, and why Mandel’s low scrap learning rate is significant to our clients.
Traditional training evaluation methods don’t provide data about the likely business impact of training. Instead, typical metrics focus on the reactions of training participants to the following:
- Overall quality of course
- Quality of support materials
- Effectiveness of instructor
- Adequacy of facilities
But, traditional metrics like the ones above won't help you build the strongest case possible for your learning investment.
Scrap learning stands out as a metric that can predict learning impact.
Scrap learning refers to the portion of training that you deliver, that your learners or trainees don't immediately apply back on the job.
How do you measure your scrap rate? By asking trainees or learners to identify the specific skills and tools they applied (or didn't apply) back on the job within six weeks of completing their training or education.
According to analysis by Corporate Executive Board (CEB) Metrics that Matter™, the average organization has a scrap learning rate of 45% — that represents a lot of wasted training time and dollars.*
Mandel takes scrap learning seriously.
In fact, we commissioned Knowledge Advisors (since acquired by Corporate Executive Board) to conduct an independent study of 2900 Mandel graduates to determine the scrap learning rate for our training programs.
The results? Mandel's scrap learning rate is just 4%. In other words, 96% of learning content was reported to be immediately relevant and applicable back on the job.
But, you might be asking, "Does a low scrap rate necessarily mean better performance?"
A recent Training Industry Magazine article authored by CEB Metrics that Matter™ senior measurement consultant, John Mattox, II, Ph.D., reveals that a low scrap learning rate strongly correlates with increased job performance.**
Organizations that actively measure scrap learning see annual employee performance gains due to learning of 10%, as compared to 6% for those that don't measure, according to "Confronting Scrap Learning," a CEB Metrics that Matter™ publication.
And, the top quartile of organizations that measure scrap see gains that more than triple those of the typical organization.***
What's the takeaway?
If you don't already measure scrap learning, start as soon as possible. If you do measure it, begin to make immediate improvements based on your analysis.
And, when you're trying to assess which learning and development partner or program will deliver the best return on your investment, mind the scrap. The lower the rate, the better.
To learn more about the results of the KnowledgeAdvisors (a CEB company) evaluation of Mandel's programs, visit http://mandel.com/clients/results.
* CEB 2014 Training Effectiveness Dashboard.
**TrainingInustry.com Magazine, Spring 2015.
***Confronting Scrap Learning – How to Address the Pervasive Water in Talent Development. Metrics That Matter™ from CEB.
Have you ever encountered an unfriendly meeting participant while presenting? Maybe you know someone who constantly interrupts, asks aggressive questions, or worse, tries to take over your meeting. Believe it or not, you have more control over these conference room bullies than you think.
Learn how to recognize these strong personalities, the things you may be doing to trigger their behavior, and what you can do right now to strengthen your command of the room and feel more confident in front of any audience.
Ann Landers’ advice still holds: “Don’t accept your dog’s admiration as conclusive evidence that you are wonderful.” Imagine it’s the night before your big presentation. You need feedback, but it sounds like your dog is off the list. Where do you go next? Self-assess. Hmm, research shows that may not be the best idea. Read the blog to find out why and learn about a new mobile app that is fast becoming a presenter's best friend.
"Too little time" is the number one concern customers raise when it comes to training. Organizations fear that pulling employees away from their jobs, even for a day or two, will negatively impact productivity and performance. To mitigate this perceived risk some opt to drastically shorten training or, worse, skip it altogether. But cutting corners on the one skill every single employee uses every day could cost you in ways you hadn't imagined. Read the blog to learn why and what you can do about it.
You’ve no doubt felt the impact of poor communication at some point in your life. What’s less clear is just how much poor communication costs. Specifically, how much does it cost the typical business? According to this first-of-its-kind 2017 report on workplace productivity, the price may shock you. Find out what it is and why getting specific is critical to making the case for training investment.
My experience, first as a client of Mandel's who received Train-the-Trainer Certification and now as Mandel’s own senior director of global training services, gives me a unique perspective on why “trainer training” in communication skills can be so powerful. Here are the top 3 benefits I believe companies gain when their own trainers get certified to deliver communication skills training.
Clients often ask, “What’s the best metric for measuring training?” It can be difficult to tie communication skills training directly to cost savings or performance gains. Difficult, but not impossible. You just have to use the right metric. And, that means taking an honest look at how much of your training is going to waste.
- Welcome to the Future of Sales (Hint: It’s Virtual)
- Listen Closely: Your Company Culture Depends On It
- How to Deliver Impactful, Engaging Hybrid Meetings
- Leading a Virtual Team Means Doing Things Differently
- Are You Really Listening?
- 4 Listening Tips for Improving Your Virtual Meetings
- The Irresistible Power of Stories in Virtual Selling
- The Top Sales Skill for 2021!
- Top Virtual Communication Mistakes – and How to Overcome Them in 2021!
- Tell a Story. Close a Deal. Even on Zoom.